Re: King Standard Gandalf Choke & Morc/Sauron Grind

[Phallen Cassidy]

I toyed with the hybrid grind a few ways and in the end, there's just no reason for it. Orc Bowmen is just more efficient than any minion could be and is just too natural of a fit with Under the Watching Eye. In the games I've managed to assign Morgul Spearman, I would have already ended the game with Sauron Grind. These minions are better left as support for Morgul Brute and Morgul Destroyer, they're just another way of of doing the same thing: exerting the Ring-bearer another time or putting wounds on the fighting companions.

I wound up rebuilding it with non-tracker Orcs and corruption. Desperate Defense of the Ring with fierce Nazgul does a number on a Fellowship. You need fewer Orcs in the deck since they've got higher vitality and a single Orc can play several conditions. Their higher strength means there's rarely an easy out for Thin and Stretched, especially for players using Answer to All Riddles. Morgul Skulker can dampen its effectiveness, but he's crucial for putting It Wants to Be Found or some key Nazgul back in rotation.

The deck works pretty well, and has far fewer condition discarding woes since the damage is much harder to undo (particularly for the very popular Elf-Man fellowships). Still, I was left with a dire problem: the deck title no longer fit without the "red rovers." And I was so proud of that title! I looked for some reason -- any reason -- to put a tracker in play for a Nazgul deck. The only Sauron cards to key off tracker specifically are Seeking It Always, UtWE, and Spies of Mordor. Seeking It Always is no good after Fellowship block, UtWE I had already tried, and Spies of Mordor wouldn't actually benefit from the trackers. I'd Make You Squeak is there and Nazgul always love some more twilight, but it and UtWE were too many exertions, plus the Morcs were already plenty capable of putting wounds on Frodo, leaving it once again better for regular Orcs. There's simply no reason to do it.

Except! And some of you may have realized this already. The set 7 initiative trackers would make simply discarding cards for DDotR a very unappealing choice. I had already put a few in the corruption deck, so I swapped out the remaining big guys (even Orc Archer Troop, who is probably not a tracker for balance reasons. A real deck should keep that one ) and came up with this:

Ring-bearer: Frodo, Reluctant Adventurer
Ring: The One Ring, Such a Weight to Carry

Adventure deck:
Isengard Ruined
King's Tent
Hall of the Kings
Osgiliath Fallen
Pelennor Flat
Minas Tirith Fifth Circle
Ruined Capitol
Morgulduin
Slag Mounds

Free Peoples Draw Deck (36):
1x Gandalf, The White Wizard
1x Smeagol, Poor Creature
1x Pippin, Hobbit of Some Intelligence
1x Sam, Proper Poet
1x Thrarin, Dwarven Smith
2x Barliman Butterbur, Prancing Pony Proprietor
2x Bounder
1x Old Noakes, Purveyor of Wisdoms
2x Glamdring, Lightning Brand
2x Brace of Coneys
2x Sting, Baggins Heirloom
2x Gandalf's Staff, Focus of Power
1x Mithril-coat
2x Deep in Thought
3x Depart Silently
2x Mysterious Wizard
2x Roll of Thunder
3x Servant of the Secret Fire
2x Terrible and Evil
3x Moment of Respite

Shadow Draw Deck (36):
2x Grishnakh, Orc Captain
4x Orc Chaser
4x Orc Pursuer(2)
2x Orc Stalker
3x The Witch-king, Morgul King
2x Úlairë Attëa, Keeper of Dol Guldur
1x Úlairë Cantëa, Faster Than Winds
2x Úlairë Cantëa, Lieutenant of Dol Guldur
1x Úlairë Enquëa, Lieutenant of Morgul
2x Úlairë Lemenya, Assailing Minion
3x Úlairë Toldëa, Messenger of Morgul
2x Disposable Servants
1x Fear
2x Dead Marshes
4x Desperate Defense of the Ring
1x Out of Sight and Shot

I had pared it down to 34 at one point before bringing it up to 36, I am using Poor Creature aggressively to find DDotR as soon as possible and have decked myself at site 7 depending on the draws. It might need to go back to 38 but ket was right, when you're looking for 4 specific cards you want the deck as trim as possible. The Free Peoples strategy is still the same even if a few cards are different, I upped the quantity on all the expensive permanents in hopes of getting them out as soon as possible. I'm not bidding anymore, if the opportunity presents itself to pass my opponent I take it but I'm not trying to make that happen most of the time. This version of Glamdring lets me put away minions much more easily, though I'm not sure if it's really better than using Gandalf's Staff, Walking Stick and Shadowfax (or either of the other Glamdrings, for that matter)

Thin and Stretched misses too often with Orc Pursuer and even Orc Chaser, so it had to go. Disposable Servants can fill the need for cycling on the Shadow side and since the opponent's hand is already reduced to the most valuable cards thanks to DDotR it's plenty of threats for WK. I'm going back and forth on whether to try Enduring Evil instead -- it would certainly be a surprise.

The neat thing is that Ulaire Toldea, Messenger of Morgul can assign himself to Arwen, Fair Elf Maiden bearing Gwemegil and Asfaloth, lose the skirmish, and then assign himself to her again to die. Why? Well when she's stacked with 2 DDotR, not only have I just added 2-3 burdens but I've also deprived my opponent of a chance to exhaust her with Gwemegil and get her killed by one of the Orcs. Finally using that high strength against her

All-in-all, I'm much happier with this version. The Free Peoples are a bit silly but fun to navigate, and the Shadow side can be downright terrifying when it comes together.