Post your Gemp-LotR bugs here

[MarcinS]

Site 7 http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=yox1$n1agqjpa8xx6nowf

Argument ready to hand is bugged,it discarded 6minions including 5 trolls and 1 orc without giving me the option too choose race or whatever.

Fixed (after restart):
- "Argument Ready to Hand" now asks the Shadow player to choose a race, rather than FP player.

[TelTura]

Game crashed out of nowhere, refreshed, both me and the other guy had no images, locked up.  jammed concede and it let me out.

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=ketura$inw91o4ohp5vykvm

[MarcinS]

Game crashed out of nowhere, refreshed, both me and the other guy had no images, locked up.  jammed concede and it let me out.

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?replayId=ketura$inw91o4ohp5vykvm

Fixed (after restart):
- Game no longer freezes in rare cases (when it was assigned by non-standard means), when a minion is removed from skirmish, before it resolves.

[ket_the_jet]

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?gameId=128

My understanding is that ambush is assigned per minion as he or she is assigned [see CRD 4.0]. With this in mind, I assigned a Suzerain of Harad before assigning a Southron Chieftain; the should not have been added.

Frankly, that resulted in me being #$&*@! in a league game.
-wtk

Edit: More on that here.

[Gil-Estel]

You are correct. From the CRD:

When the Free Peoples player assigns one of his
characters to skirmish a minion with the keyword
"ambush ?," the Shadow player who owns that
minion may add ?. (See assignment phase.)
If your minion with ambush ¤ is assigned by the
Free Peoples player, you may add two tokens to
the twilight pool. The Free Peoples player may
decide not to assign any characters to your minion
with ambush, allowing you to assign it later in the
assignment phase.

[bibfortuna25]

It doesn't matter what order you assigned them. As long as FP assigned both the Southron Chieftain and the Suzerain of Harad during FP's normal assignment, both of them will trigger.

[MarcinS]

@ket_the_jet

Here is what happened (with rule explanations in quotations):
1. You assigned minions (Suzerain of Harad and Southron Chieftain) to your characters, the assignment take effect simultaneously, there is no order of assigning - "Once all assignments have been made, they take effect simultaneously."
2. Required action from Southron Chieftain triggers and shadow player gains initiative.
3. Check for optional actions is made, and Suzerain of Harad sees that shadow player has initiative, hence it has Ambush (8).

[hsiale]

MuadDib85 somehow managed to play 11 games in series 4 of Towers Sealed league.

[ket_the_jet]

@ket_the_jet

Here is what happened (with rule explanations in quotations):
1. You assigned minions (Suzerain of Harad and Southron Chieftain) to your characters, the assignment take effect simultaneously, there is no order of assigning - "Once all assignments have been made, they take effect simultaneously."
2. Required action from Southron Chieftain triggers and shadow player gains initiative.
3. Check for optional actions is made, and Suzerain of Harad sees that shadow player has initiative, hence it has Ambush (8).

I understand that is how it happened, but it took a little more reading of the CRD [under assignment, and not under ambush] to understand why it happened.

Sorry for any potential overreaction. I guess this is the one exception to "nothing happens simultaneously."
-wtk

[bibfortuna25]

Well, technically, the assignments don't happen simultaneously. It's just that very rarely are there any cards that would take advantage of that. If there are two minions that have a mandatory action of "When this minion is assigned, do X," the FP will decide which minion triggers first.

[MarcinS]

Well, technically, the assignments don't happen simultaneously. It's just that very rarely are there any cards that would take advantage of that. If there are two minions that have a mandatory action of "When this minion is assigned, do X," the FP will decide which minion triggers first.

Assignments do happen simultaneously, just the triggers and responses to this event (assignments) are played one at a time, first required then optional of course.

[Alkarin]

hi, i think is a bug, site 5 from SoG, Crashed Gate is not accepted in Movie League.
And Rohirrim Army too..

[MarcinS]

hi, i think is a bug, site 5 from SoG, Crashed Gate is not accepted in Movie League.

First week of the Movie League is sets 1-7.

[MarcinS]

My opponent played Goblin Archer (Jesus...why?) at Steward's Tomb and took archery fire from my Garrison of Gondor.
-wtk

http://www.gempukku.com/gemp-lotr/game.html?gameId=239

Was there another Orc to spot? I guess not. I can't see the replay, as you've given a link to the game (already finished), not the replay.

[Gartax]

Capture by the ring add a threat even if gollum is not played.